Adli Belge İncelemelerinde Adli Psikiyatrinin Rolü - Olgu Sunumu

Authors

Yasin Koca
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7097-7544
Sermet Koç

Synopsis

This study highlights the critical role of considering the effects of neurodegenerative diseases such as Parkinson's, alcohol or substance use, and advanced age on handwriting and signatures in forensic document examinations. Handwriting and signatures represent a complex process shaped by the combined function of anatomical, neurological, and physiological systems, which over time develop a person-specific automatization. Parkinson's disease causes significant deterioration in handwriting and signature characteristics due to bradykinesia, tremor, micrographia, and alterations in pressure and speed. In the presented case, a signature attributed to an individual with Parkinson's disease was analytically compared with reference documents dating prior to the disease, 10 months before, and 8 months after the contested document. The comparative analysis revealed that the questioned signature was an imitation of the person's original pre-illness signature, thereby establishing forgery. This demonstrates that forensic document examiners reaching conclusions solely based on visual comparison samples without knowledge of the individual's clinical condition and medical history may arrive at erroneous results.

References

Uzun N & Alkan N. Alzheimer Hastalığı ve Elyazısına Etkisi. Düşünen Adam; 2001, 14(4): 232-236.

Caligiuri MP & Mohammed L. Signature dynamics in Alzheimer's disease. Forensic science international; 2019, 302, 109880

Yılmaz R. (2015). Adli Belge İncelemelerinde Terminoloji. İsmail Birincioğlu (Ed.) 3. Tıp Hukuku Günleri: Adli Belge İncelemeleri “Prof. Dr. Hayrettin Dalokay Anısına” içinde (S.56-70). İstanbul: Türk Tabipleri Birliği İstanbul Tabip Odası

Okumuş H, Kırcı GS, Aydoğdu Hİ, et al. Adli Belge İncelemelerinin 780 Olgu Üzerinden Değerlendirilmesi Trabzon 2007-2013. Adli Tıp Bülteni; 2016, 21(1), 26-30.

Özdemir V, Cantürk G, Şahin H. Yazı yüzeyi olarak kullanılan kadın iç çamaşırının adli belge niteliğinde incelenmesi: olgu sunumu. Adli Tıp Dergisi;2004, 18(3-4): 42-49.

Aşıcıoğlu F. 2007. (Ed). Adli Bilimlerde El yazısı ve İmza İncelemeleri içinde (S.33-121). Öner Matbaacılık, 1. Baskı, İstanbul.

Alkan N, Fincancı ŞK, Arıcan N, et al. Yaş Cinsiyet ve Eğitime Bağlı Yazı ve İmza Değişiklikleri. Adli Tıp Bülteni; 1996, 1(3), 116-121

Alkan N, Sözen MŞ, Kurtaş Ö. Dünyada adli belge incelemesi. The Bulletin of Legal Medicine; 1998, 3(2), 61-66.

Schäfer, A. Graphology in German psychiatry (1870–1930). History of psychiatry; 2016, 27(3), 307-319.

Gökçal E, Gür VE, Selvitop R, et al. İdiyopatik Parkinson Hastalığında Motor ve Non-motor Semptomlar ve Yaşam kalitesine Etkileri. Noro-Psikyatri Arsivi; 2017, 54(2): 143.

Van Gemmert AW, Teulings HL, Stelmach GE. The influence of mental and motor load on handwriting movements in Parkinsonian patients. Acta psychologica; 1998, 100(1-2): 161-175.

Smits EJ, Tolonen AJ, Cluitmans L, et al. Standardized handwriting to assess bradykinesia, micrographia and tremor in Parkinson's disease. PloS one; 2014, 9(5), e97614.

Rosenblum S, Samuel M, Zlotnik S, et al. Handwriting as an objective tool for Parkinson’s disease diagnosis. Journal of neurology; 2013, 260(9), 2357-2361.

Shukla AW, Ounpraseuth S, Okun MS, et al. Micrographia and related deficits in Parkinson's disease: a cross-sectional study. BMJ open; 2012, 2(3).

Walton J. Handwriting changes due to aging and Parkinson's syndrome. Forensic science international; 1997, 88(3), 197-214.

Lewitt PA. Micrographia as a focal sign of neurological disease. Journal of neurology, neurosurgery, and psychiatry; 1983, 46(12), 1152.

Caligiuri MP, Teulings HL, Dean CE, et al. Handwriting movement kinematics for quantifying extrapyramidal side effects in patients treated with atypical antipsychotics. Psychiatry research; 2010, 177(1-2), 77-83.

Caligiuri MP, Teulings HL, Dean CE, et al. A quantitative measure of handwriting dysfluency for assessing tardive dyskinesia. Journal of clinical psychopharmacology; 2015, 35(2), 168.

Dean DJ, Teulings HL, Caligiuri M, et al. Handwriting analysis indicates spontaneous dyskinesias in neuroleptic naive adolescents at high risk for psychosis. Journal of visualized experiments: JoVE; 2013, (81).

Published

October 14, 2021

License

License