Sınır Mental Kapasite Olgularının Hukuki Yönden Toplumsal Farkedilebilirlik Düzeylerinin Değerlendirilmesi

Authors

Nursel Gamsız Bilgin; Hakan Kar; Halis Dokgöz; Gökhan Aktürk; Ebru Yaşat Aksay

Synopsis

This study examines the importance of forensic psychiatric evaluation in determining whether the mental status of individuals with mild mental retardation and borderline intellectual functioning can be recognized by the public, particularly by their partners, in cases where they fall victim to sexual assault. Although individuals with borderline intellectual functioning (IQ 70-85) experience cognitive and social limitations, they are often evaluated alongside mild mental retardation, and because distinguishing them from the general population is difficult, they become highly vulnerable to exploitation. Under the Turkish Penal Code, evaluating the ability to perceive the "moral wrongfulness" of a sexual act, the capacity for self-defense physically and mentally, and mistake regarding the material elements of an offense that eliminates intent holds significant importance in judicial proceedings. In the presented case of a 25-year-old female epilepsy patient diagnosed with mild mental retardation and borderline intellectual functioning across different IQ tests, it was concluded that she could not defend herself physically or mentally against the alleged act and that her condition could be recognized by a normal person living or sharing a relationship with her. The study concludes that determining whether the victim's mental condition can be understood by non-physicians requires a holistic assessment involving not only the victim, but also the perpetrator's mental state, the duration of their relationship, and the overall context of the incident.

References

Shevell I.M, Swaiman F.K. Global developmental delay and mental retardation. In Swaiman F K, Ashwal S ed. Pediatric Neurology. Third edition. Philadelphia: Mosby 1999: 551-60

Evans BO. Mental Retardation. In: Evans BO Ed. Manual of Child Neurology. Edinburg, 1987; 149-57

Daily DK, Ardinger HH, Holmes GE. Identification and evaluation of mental retardation. Am Fam Physician. 2000 Feb 15;61(4):1059-67, 1070. Erratum in: Am Fam Physician 2000 Sep 1;62(5):961-3. PMID: 10706158.

Deciding mental retardation and mental illness in capital cases: The effects of procedure, evidence, and attitudes Psychology, Crime & Law Volume 13, 2007 - Issue 6 Pages 537-557 | Received 21 Jul 2005, Published online: 07 Dec 2007 Margaret c. Reardon,

PETERSILIA J. Justice for All? Offenders with Mental Retardation and the California Corrections System. The Prison Journal. 1997;77(4):358-380. doi:10.1177/0032855597077004002

Guan W, Cai WX, Huang FY, Wu JS. [The application of diminished criminal responsibility rating scale to mental retardation offenders]. Fa Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2009 Oct;25(5):352-4. Chinese. PMID: 20000044.

Wilson C, Seaman L, Nettelbeck T. Vulnerability to criminal exploitation: influence of interpersonal competence differences among people with mental retardation. J Intellect Disabil Res. 1996 Feb;40 ( Pt 1):8-16. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2788.1996.tb00597.x. PMID: 8930052.

Peltopuro, M., Ahonen, T., Kaartinen, J., Seppälä, H., & Närhi, V. (2014). Borderline intellectual functioning: a systematic literature review. Intellectual and developmental disabilities, 52(6), 419- 443.

Mikton C, Maguire H, Shakespeare T. A systematic review of the effectiveness of interventions to prevent and respond to violence against persons with disabilities. J Interpers Violence 2014;29(17):3207-26 doi: 10.1177/0886260514534530. Pubmed PMID: 24870959-11

Sullivan PM, Knutson JF. Maltreatment and disabilities: a population-based epidemiological study. Child Abuse Negl 2000;24(10):1257-73. Pubmed PMID: 11075694.

Jones L, Bellis MA, Wood S, Hughes K, McCoy E, Eckley L, Bates G, Mikton C, Shakespeare T, Officer A. Prevalance and risk of violence against children with disabilities: a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies. Lancet 2012;380:899-907. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(12)60692-8. Pubmed PMID: 22795511.,

Manders CE, Stoneman Z. Children with disabilities in the child protective services system: An analog study of investigation and case management. Child Abuse Negl 2009;33:229-37. doi: 10.1016/j.chiabu.2008.10.001. Pubmed PMID: 19348941.

Oral G, Adli Psikiyatri, Editörler Soysal Z, Çakalır C, Adli Tıp, İstanbul;1999: 1377-1573

Biçer Ü, Tırtıl L,Kurtaş Ö,Aker T, Adli Psikiyatri, Birinci Basamakta Adli Tıp, Editörler:Koç S, Can M,İstanbul Tabip Odası, İstanbul;2009

TÜRK CEZA KANUNU, Kanun Numarası: 5237, Kabul Tarihi: 20.09.2004, Yayımlandığı Resmî Gazete Tarihi: 12.10.2004 Resmî Gazete Sayısı: 25611

Türk Ceza Kanunu İle Bazı Kanunlarda Değişiklik Yapılmasına Dair Kanun. Kanun Numarası: 6545, Kabul Tarihi: 18.06.2014, Yayımlandığı Resmi Gazete Tarihi: 28.06.2014, Yayımlandığı Resmi Gazete Sayısı: 29044

Şenol, Ender, et al. "Cinsel saldırı olguları için düzenlenen adli psikiyatrik raporların incelenmesi." The Bulletin of Legal Medicine 21.3 (2016): 159-166.

Published

October 14, 2021

License

License