Ceza Sorumluluğunun Değerlendirilmesinde Olay Tarihli Ruhsal Muayenenin Önemi: Bir Olgu Sunumu
Synopsis
This study addresses the importance of forensic psychiatric examination and medical records from the date of the incident in evaluating criminal responsibility through a case report. A 30-year-old male individual was referred for the evaluation of his criminal capacity under Article 32 of the Turkish Penal Code (TCK) due to acts of "simple injury and damage to property" committed 2 years prior. Examination of his forensic and medical records revealed that hours before the incident on the same day, he was brought to the emergency department due to disorganized and aggressive behavior, as well as persecutory, reference, and grandiose delusions; however, while his transfer to a closed psychiatric ward was being arranged, he fled the hospital and subsequently became involved in the offense. Upon being brought back to the emergency service by the police later that evening, a mental status examination determined that his reality testing and judgment were impaired, leading to his admission to a psychiatric ward. Although no pathological findings were observed during his examination 2 years later, the detailed mental status records from the day of the incident established that he was under the influence of a mental illness (Bipolar Disorder) at the time of the act, could not comprehend the legal meaning and consequences of his actions, and had significantly diminished capacity to direct his conduct, leading to the conclusion that he had no criminal responsibility under TCK 32/1. Consequently, performing a comprehensive psychiatric evaluation alongside physical examinations during initial admissions plays a critical role in ensuring justice.
References
Şahin E, Ceza Yargılamasının tarihçesi. TAAD. 2014;18:349-385.
Toroslu H, Toroslu N, Ceza Hukuku Genel Kısım. Savaş Yayınları.Ankara. 2018.
Artuk ME, Gökcen A, Alşahin ME, Çakır K, Ceza Hukuku Genel Hükümler.Ankara. 2017.
Özbek VO, Bacaksız P, Doğan K, Ceza Hukuku Bilgisi, Genel Hükümler. Seçkin Yayıncılık, Ankara. 2006.
Biçer U, Tırtıl L, Kurtaş Ö, Aker T, Adli Psikiyatri. Koç S, Can M, Birinci Basamakta Adli Tıp. İstanbul Tabip Odası.2. Baskı. 2011: 242-252.
Dinçmen K, Adli Psikiyatri. Birlik Yayınları. İstanbul. 1984; 16-9.
Türk Ceza Kanunu, https://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/MevzuatMetin/1.5.5237.pdf
Tırtıl L, Biçer Ü, Oral G, Adli Psikiyatri. Dokgöz H, Adli Tıp ve Adli Bilimler.Akademisyen Kitabevi. Ankara. 2019; 541-579.
Öncü F, Sercan M, Ceza Hukukunda Adli Psikiyatri-Ceza Sorumluluğunun Belirlenmesi. Uygur N, Adli Psikiyatri Uygulama Kılavuzu.TPD yayınları. Ankara. 2018; 33-65.
Oral G, Adli Tıp ve Ruhsal Bozukluklar-Adli Psikiyatri.Adli Tıp Ders Kitabı.İstanbul. 2011; 551-594.